104 Followers
66 Following
arbieroo

Arbie's Unoriginally Titled Book Blog

It's a blog! Mainly of book reviews.

Currently reading

Prized Possessions
Quentin Buvelot, David Taylor, Rupert Goulding
Progress: 86/192 pages
The Penguin Book of Russian Poetry
Robert Chandler
The Uncertain Land and Other Poems
Patrick O'Brian
Progress: 6/160 pages
The Poems and Plays of John Masefield
John Masefield
Progress: 76/534 pages
Empires of the Word: A Language History of the World
Nicholas Ostler
Progress: 246/615 pages
Blue at the Mizzen (Aubrey/Maturin #20)
Patrick O'Brian
Progress: 73/272 pages
Selected Poems
U A Fanthorpe
Progress: 16/160 pages
Hainish Novels & Stories, Vol. 2
Ursula K. Le Guin
Progress: 133/789 pages
The Art Book
Editors of Phaidon Press
Progress: 11/515 pages
The Essential Shakespeare
Ted Hughes
Progress: 78/259 pages

Hard to be a God, Arkady & Boris Strugatsky

Hard To Be A God (S.F. MASTERWORKS) - Boris Strugatsky, Arkady Strugatsky

The more I think about this book the better it gets.

 

It starts rather abruptly with a prologue that shows three youngsters wandering around a wilderness to no real purpose. The real function of this prologue isn't clear until the epilogue...

 

Then suddenly everyone has grown up and we're on a different planet which is remarkably like Earth (same ecology, humans live in a feudal society with mediaeval technology) a bizarre coincidence that is never addressed. We also learn that back home on Earth a genuinely Communist society has taken root globally and technology has advanced greatly - interstellar travel is practised, after all. The visitors from Earth are historical observers - they are supposed to be collecting data to support the prevaling theory of history which dictates that there is only one eventual result of human history - the Communist State of course. But things seem to be going wrong - an alarming individual, a minister to the King, seems to be trying to eliminate all centres of learning and all literate individuals. Is it a bid to establish a Totalitarian State? That shouldn't happen according to the accepted theory of history.

 

The observers from Earth are not supposed to interfere, but it's hard to be a god and remain aloof when surrounded by misery, disease, ignorance, brutality and persecution. What's the right thing to do?

 

It's a thematically complex novel that nevertheless could be read by a young person simply as a kind of adventure tale. Unsurprisingly many of the themes are political; censorship and suppression of learning, Totalitarianism and will to power, Communist theory, religious oppression, but some are as much ethical: is interference in an attempt to improve the lot of the masses justified or not? And (perhaps the most interesting and unexpected to me) if you take a person from an ideal society, Utopian, safe, stable, moral, with fair and equal distribution of resources and put him in the antithetical situation, largely isolated from his peers, what happens? Does he maintain the moral code of home, or does the society around him eventually corrupt him? What exactly happens at the end is left a little ambiguous but the implication is clear. The impact is made clear in the epilogue, back on Earth, with the three friends from the prologue re-united.

 

There's an afterword to this translation which appears to date back to 1997, by the surviving Strugatsky brother. It's as fascinating as the book itself, setting a context for its writing that is very illuminating. Initially a straight-forward SF adventure story in the vein of Dumas' Musketeers novels was the sole aim, but it was the early 1960s and the political situation in Russia inevitably reared its ugly head. A furore arose regarding whether the SF community's younger elements' satirical and critical attacks on the status quo of political oppression, ever changing approved political doctrine, hypocrisy were allowable. Older writers, government shills, were loudly complaining. The regime was visibly critical of much of the new art, visual, literary or even musical. Was there going to be a crack-down?

 

Well, the Strugatskies decided to risk it and turned their prospective piece of pure escapism into an attack on those in power, Communist theory, Totalitarianism in general and the will to power of individuals. The crack-down never came and the book was not treated severely by the censors, though their editor persuaded the authors to change the name of the villain from Rebia (anagram of Beria, a prominent politician of the time) to the marginally more subtle Reba.

 

The other thing the afterword establishes is that there was a thriving market for SF in Soviet era Russia, big enough to have a society specifically for SF authors, a fact that it would be hard to believe given only the evidence of what has been published in English translation. Another observation is that just as social and political concerns are frequently explored in English language SF, so they were in the Russian SF of that time, with the same somewhat reduced level of scrutiny by dismissive people in power. (Compare with Solzhenitsyn, who published One Day in the Life of Ivan Denisovich in 1962, the same year Hard to be a God was being written).

 

I'll certainly be looking for the other Strugatsky books with editions in English but I'm also interested in picking up any other Russian SF available in translation to further compare and contrast the trends and themes of Russian and Anglo-American SF.

Reading progress update: I've read 28 out of 96 pages.

Robert Browning - Douglas Dunn

The Pied Piper of Hamelyn: A most vivacious re-telling of the tale.

Reading progress update: I've read 207 out of 615 pages.

Empires of the Word: A Language History of the World - Nicholas Ostler

Sanskrit was the first language to be spread by ship (India --> Sri Lanka).

Reading progress update: I've read 156 out of 2016 pages.

Thomas Middleton: The Collected Works -  MacDonald P. Jackson (Editor),  John Jowett (Editor),  John Lavagnino,  V. Wayne, Gary Taylor, Thomas Middleton

The Nighingale and the Ante (manuscript): A pleasant introductory poem explains that as the sun was setting, Philomel, lately in the form of a nightingale (see Ovid's Metamorphoses), caught ant that successfully begged for its life and began to tell it's own tale of changing its form.

Reading progress update: I've read 154 out of 2016 pages.

Thomas Middleton: The Collected Works -  MacDonald P. Jackson (Editor),  John Jowett (Editor),  John Lavagnino,  V. Wayne, Gary Taylor, Thomas Middleton

Father Hubburd's Tales: Anybody read/know anything about Thomas Nashe? His name keeps coming up in the introduction as a fellow satirist.

Reading progress update: I've read 35 out of 192 pages.

Prized Possessions - Quentin Buvelot, David Taylor, Rupert Goulding

Flagon says, roar! "Still Life with Flagon!" Turns out to just be a container for liquids. :-(

Reading progress update: I've read 153 out of 2016 pages.

Thomas Middleton: The Collected Works -  MacDonald P. Jackson (Editor),  John Jowett (Editor),  John Lavagnino,  V. Wayne, Gary Taylor, Thomas Middleton

It seems that pamphlets were the natural home of satire during this period and Father Hubburd's Tales is another example.

Reading progress update: I've read 31 out of 192 pages.

Prized Possessions - Quentin Buvelot, David Taylor, Rupert Goulding

Many paintings by 17th Century Dutch Old Masters were made in England and have never left - the artists went where the work was and a lot came from English patrons.

Reading progress update: I've read 29 out of 192 pages.

Prized Possessions - Quentin Buvelot, David Taylor, Rupert Goulding

Calling out Rachel Ruysch, female Dutch Old Master - the only one I've ever come across.I think I ought to look for a history of fine art produced by women.

Reading progress update: I've read 291 out of 438 pages.

Human Is?: A Philip K. Dick Reader (Gollancz S.F.) - Philip K. Dick

The Mold of Yancy: In which we learn a new method of creating Huxley's Brave New World.

Reading progress update: I've read 151 out of 2016 pages.

Thomas Middleton: The Collected Works -  MacDonald P. Jackson (Editor),  John Jowett (Editor),  John Lavagnino,  V. Wayne, Gary Taylor, Thomas Middleton

Next up, another pamplet, Father Hubburd's Tales, preceded by the manuscript version, The Ante and the Nightingale.

Reading progress update: I've read 20 out of 192 pages.

Prized Possessions - Quentin Buvelot, David Taylor, Rupert Goulding

Two of the pictures in this exhibition have their normal home in Dyrham Park, a country house not far outsde Bath. Despite my decades of living in the area, I've never visited. Probably should rectify that.

Reading progress update: I've read 149 out of 2016 pages.

Thomas Middleton: The Collected Works -  MacDonald P. Jackson (Editor),  John Jowett (Editor),  John Lavagnino,  V. Wayne, Gary Taylor, Thomas Middleton

News from Gravesend: Sent to Nobody
Thomas Dekker, Thomas Middleton

 

Published as a "pamphlet," a form of publication that the study of Shakespeare's work will not even reveal the existence of, this is a poem about the plague, prompted by the outbreak of 1603, which was a particularly severe one for the period. It is prefaced by an "Epistle Dedicatory" of unprecedented length, taking up nearly half the pamphlet. The dedicatee is "Nobody" a symbolic personage who is specifically not any real person. The reason for this is explained in the Epistle as a plea for a change from writers currying favour from rich patrons in order to earn a living to some other method. This and the subsequent attack on the wealthy members of the legal professions for abandoning London to its fate in favour of Winchester during plague outbreaks is all rather political and I'm surprised that it passed the censors. There's nothing directly attacking the King or the institutions of the Monarchy so perhaps they were not too bothered.

 

I'm not much familiar with the lyric poetry of the period. I've read Shakespeare's contributions and nothing else to speak of. Being neither a narrative poem, nor the sort of personal topics addressed in the sonnets, but instead a discursive examination of a topical subject with moral, political and philosophical implications, this was again unique in my experience. It's also good, with some exceptionally vivid imagery (buboes like purple grapes sticks in my mind) although the science of disease is entirely discredited, now, as is the notion put forward by the authors that it is really a God-sent punishment of the immoral.

 

A very interesting read from the perspective of learning about the Jacobean literary world and on its own terms as a literary work.

Reading progress update: I've read 147 out of 2016 pages.

Thomas Middleton: The Collected Works -  MacDonald P. Jackson (Editor),  John Jowett (Editor),  John Lavagnino,  V. Wayne, Gary Taylor, Thomas Middleton

News from Gravesend: There was a widespread misconception that people can't have two infectious illnesses at the same time, thus being syphilitic should prevent plague - both will kill you but the former much more slowly...

Reading progress update: I've read 185 out of 615 pages.

Empires of the Word: A Language History of the World - Nicholas Ostler

Sanskrit has been used continuously for ~3500 years!

Reading progress update: I've read 9 out of 192 pages.

Prized Possessions - Quentin Buvelot, David Taylor, Rupert Goulding

I'm loving the spaniel on the cover.